PROBLEM-SOLVING
AND
DECISION-MAKING
ASSESSMENT CRITERIA |
The
ability to solve problems is an essential
attribute of any business manager. A "problem" is defined as any factor
which causes an individual's/firm's actual outcomes to differ from the individual's/firm's
desired outcomes.
Problem-solving may be quantitative
in nature. With quantitative problems, there often exists
a unique solution (or set of solutions) to the problem,
furthermore, the ability of a given alternative to further
the attainment of one's goals can be proved or disproved.
Problem-solving may also be qualitative.
Unique solutions (or sets of solutions) may also exist
when problems are qualitative. The distinction is that
the validity of the proposed solution cannot be
proven, but must be assessed in terms of comparisons
of differences between actual and desired outcomes resulting
from the implementation of the chosen alternative relative
to the implementation of other alternatives.
Although the levels that
an individual masters en route to successful problem-solving
tend to parallel the steps involved
in problem-solving, we emphasize that the two are not synonymous.
An individual who successfully follows a set of instructions,
but who fails to demonstrate an understanding of the
foundation underlying those instructions, has not demonstrated
a mastery of any step of problem-solving even if the
unique solution is discovered and implemented.
Similarly, no step can be successfully
achieved without having also attained all prior steps.
For example, an individual who can adequately discern
the advantages and limitations of various quantitative
tools has not achieved this level if the person cannot
recognize problems through which these tools can be successfully
implemented.
Each of the defined steps should
be present in every situation in which problem-solving
is required. However, not every detail within any given
step will be present in every situation. Assessors of
students' problem-solving abilities must discern which
aspects within each step should be present in each circumstance. |